Monday, May 31, 2010

Open Letter to Pnina Tornai


Dear Pnina Tornai,

Recently, I have taken to watching TLC's "Say Yes to the Dress." On a loop. For hours. I'm not sure what the gimmick with Kleinfeld's is, or why they seem to feature your dresses almost exclusively on every episode, usually in the "out of the bride's budget, but exactly what the bride wants" category but sometimes in the "slutty bride" category, too. Maybe you are their chief designer. Maybe you are paying them big money to advertise your line on nationally syndicated television. Maybe Kleinfeld's is just particularly fond of you. Either way, watching the show got me interested in your gowns. Some are really quite pretty. For example:




Granted, these all differ vastly from the two gowns I have already designed for my own wedding (which may or may not fit so well at 80 years old), and I would probably only realistically wear one of the first two, but there is something in these gowns for everyone: a classic look gone modern (low waist, photo 1), a little drama (extreme tulle, photo 2), a little fairy tale flare with a tasteful detail (Cinderella ballgown with beading, photo 3), a little old-school romance (capsleeves, photo 4). If I saw any girl sporting any of these numbers at her wedding, I think I would react favourably, granted it work with her body-type and overall approach.

Some numbers, however, bore me:





Some confuse me:






(Now I know why Lady Gaga, Marie Antoinette, and the caged bird sing.)

Some I would expect and be more or less happy to see on the red carpet at the Oscars:






Most, including a fair amount of the above, are inappropriate:



Many (and your entire 2010 collection) offend me:




The rest just leave me cold.

Please don't misunderstand me, Ms. Tornai. I'm not saying that you have no talent as a dressmaker, or that your vision is always heartbreakingly wrong. Nor am I implying that your gowns haven't earned their place in the US's largest upscale wedding dress warehouse, or that they aren't loved by many free-spirited brides on Daddy's infinite budget. I guess I just wondered if you made anything for real, down-to-earth, normal girls who feel a little uncomfortable about displaying large chunks of their midriff or exposing all of their breasts (minus nipples) on what has been called the most important day of their lives. I also wondered if maybe your gowns would appeal to a larger portion of the bridal population if they weren't so bedazzled with jewels that put them well above and beyond most brides' (as per TLC's suggestion) very *reasonable* 3,000$ budget. It might be more advantageous to you, too: spending less on bling means you could spend more on fabric, which means more of your dresses could actually come to completion before they get put on the market.

Does anyone ever ask you to fill in the gaps you leave blank in her dress before her wedding?

Another thing I wondered is if you got your start in Vegas or on Carnival Cruise lines. If you are unfamiliar with these venues, I suggest you look into both: I see a bright future for you at either location.

One last note, and this, to your (indirect) patron, TLC. I am not sure who you think The Life Channel's audience is; perhaps you have grand delusions about who it should be, and that, I suppose, would be fine, too. Let me assure you, however, that the only people watching are stay-at-home whatevers, my sister, or students (like me) looking for any excuse to procrastinate. None of us makes millions. We are not Paris Hilton or Kim Kardashian, nor do we dress like them. I don't think very many of us have 11,000$ to spend on rhinestones and chiffon. If you are looking to be a network exemplary of your audience, you might reconsider the role Pnina Tornai plays in "Say Yes to the Dress" for the sake of consistency.

Maggie Sottero is far less glam, that's undeniably true, but she makes decent wedding gowns for 1,500$ if you want them, and many of us do.

Truly yours,
CCB

Friday, May 28, 2010

You ARE the weakest link


So, just out of curiosity, what is it that these pictures:








































have in common with this picture?




They come from the same wedding.

"What?!" you ask, "but the midnight blue gowns, even if the shawls are hugely overbearing, with the mother-of-pearl coral necklaces would have looked SO much nicer with a cool silver or slate grey palette on the groomsmen." Yes. Yes, you are right. "And the bride could have just chosen rhinestone beading over pewter in the bodice, and that would have held everything together." Right again. You're doing so well, reader. "Are you sure this is from the same wedding? Same bride? Same everything?" I wish I were lying.


I mean, if you disregard the mortal sin of combining red and pink tastelessly and thoughtlessly, you might even call this wedding regal ... crowns and all.

"Yes. Such a royal flop, the failure is almost poetic."

Almost.